FM College ~ News & Articles

Energy Group Slams International Code Council Over Model Building Rules

Mar 22, 2024 | Public | 0 comments

On March 18, the International Code Council’s (ICC) board of directors made determinations on a series of appeals to the draft 2024 International Energy Conservation Code (IECC), thus finalizing the latest model code that sets minimum energy efficiency requirements for new commercial and residential buildings.

The American Council for an Energy-Efficient Economy (ACEEE), a nonprofit research and policy group, has released a scathing statement against the ICC claiming the council chose “special interests” over key decarbonization measures. When reached for comment, the ICC’s CEO provided Facilities Management Advisor with a statement reaffirming the finalized code. Below are both statements in full.

ACEEE Statement

The International Code Council announced on Wednesday night that it had finalized its new model energy code by unilaterally stripping key energy efficiency and decarbonization measures developed by stakeholder consensus. The ICC’s board of directors overturned the supermajority votes of its residential and commercial consensus committees, the findings of its expert staff, and the judgment of its appeals board in favor of unfounded and inadmissible complaints by a handful of special interests. The ICC board made its decision after a two-hour hearing, despite three years of deliberation by its committees and three days of hearings by its appeals board.

The residential and commercial building provisions of the draft 2024 IECC were reached by consensus among industry organizations, state and local government officials, and energy efficiency advocates, including ACEEE. A new process that limited local governments’ role in developing the IECC resulted in fewer energy efficiency gains than the last code cycle, but included important initial steps to ensure new buildings are wired for electric vehicle (EV) charging, include energy-efficient heating systems, and provide the electrical outlets needed for homeowners to install a heat pump water heater. The ICC then violated its own policies for hearing appeals so it could accommodate a handful of special interests. The ICC’s board accepted several of those appeals, stripping measures that would have benefited homeowners and businesses that will now be burdened with the cost of expensive retrofits in the future.

“The International Code Council bent over backward to accommodate a few powerful industries, calling into question the organization’s legitimacy,” said Michael Waite, director of codes and building standards at ACEEE. “When the International Code Council broke its own rules to hear appeals from special interests, we thought the code council had reached its nadir. But the board’s last-minute decision to go against the people they selected and the process they themselves stood up represents a new low. Perhaps most disappointing is the ICC board’s disregard for the high retrofit costs they have decided to stick homeowners and businesses with in the future.”

The appeals by representatives of gas utilities, apartment building developers, and HVAC equipment manufacturers contended that the IECC’s scope and intent did not allow for provisions aimed at decarbonizing homes, removing the bias against electric heat pumps in commercial buildings, and providing charging infrastructure for electric vehicles. When the ICC stood up the new process for 2024 IECC development, it claimed to be “leading the way” on “a path forward on energy and sustainability to confront a changing climate.” During the 2024 IECC development process, ICC staff repeatedly confirmed to the consensus committees that the decarbonization measures they were considering were within the IECC’s scope and intent. Yet in the board’s decision, it decided that measures its members “viewed as concerning greenhouse gas reduction” would be removed from the code’s requirements to optional appendices, even though the ICC’s written procedures give the board members no authority to write the IECC themselves. Without holding any public hearings on the subject, they further removed other optional appendices intended for jurisdictions that want more advanced energy codes.

“The International Code Council is not serious about confronting climate change,” Waite said. “Not only can we not take the International Code Council seriously as a partner in achieving the level of building energy performance we need, but it also cannot even be considered an honest administrator of its own processes. With the appeals board’s rejection of the appeals, we thought the International Code Council might finally be turning a corner toward making much more progress in the face of climate change. Sadly, we were wrong.”

ICC Statement from CEO Dominic Sims

“After a review by the International Code Council’s board of directors concerning appeals on the 2024 edition of the International Energy Conservation Code (IECC), we have announced the board’s decisions, effectively finalizing the 2024 IECC. This iteration of the IECC marks a significant stride in energy efficiency, with residential and commercial buildings expected to achieve 6.5% and 10% more energy efficiency, respectively, over the 2021 edition.

“The board has opted to make certain provisions opt-in, such as EV charging infrastructure and electrification, to allow states and jurisdictions to tailor their approach to sustainability. These additions offer a range of solutions to help jurisdictions meet their sustainability goals in ways that best suit local circumstances. The 2024 IECC represents an advancement toward the goal of net zero by 2030.”

ICC’s full announcement on the board’s decision is available here.

ALSO READ: Back to Basics: Understanding Building Codes

The post Energy Group Slams International Code Council Over Model Building Rules appeared first on Facilities Management Advisor.


Submit a Comment

3 considerations for designing healthy, adaptable student dining

Every student life project possesses its own unique reflection of the campus in which it resides. Student dining facilities...

Downtown Edmonton plaza opens to public

Centennial Plaza in downtown Edmonton is now open, offering an attractive, family-friendly and accessible space. Located in...

40+ courses on renewable energy transitions, technology and financing

Editor’s note: This is part of a series on closing the sustainability skills gap with the resources available right now....

Making the Case for Infrared Heating Solutions in Warehouses

Although the summer might seem like an odd time to be thinking about heating, it could be the perfect opportunity to get...

Geisinger Medical Center Expansion Project Announced

The $880 million project is slated to be complete and open in 2028. Geisinger officials announced major plans to make...